Baseball has no dedicated betting community on Reddit and somehow still has the best coverage of any sport. Here is how that happened.
r/MLBbets was banned. There is no replacement, and nobody built one. On paper that should make baseball the worst-served sport on Reddit.
It is the best-served, by a wide margin. Through the summer, the two baseball threads on r/sportsbook carry more comments than everything else on the subreddit combined.
The two threads that matter
| Thread | What goes in it | Daily comments |
|---|---|---|
| MLB Props and Home Run Picks | Player props, strikeout totals, hits, home run bets. The single busiest thread on r/sportsbook in summer. | 413 to 724 |
| MLB Betting and Picks | Moneylines, run lines, totals, first five innings, team totals. | 239 to 582 |
Both follow the standard naming format with the weekday after two forward slashes, and a fresh pair goes up every day. Nothing carries over, which means a good writeup posted on Tuesday is buried by Wednesday. Our guide to the r/sportsbook daily threads covers the whole system.
The reason baseball works so well in this format is the schedule. Fifteen games a day, every day, for six months. That is a volume of action no other sport produces, and a daily thread is exactly the right container for it. Football gets one big day a week. Baseball gets a hundred and sixty-two.
Why the props thread is the busiest
Baseball props are unusually approachable. A starting pitcher’s strikeout total is a single-variable question with a lot of public data behind it, and the same applies to hits, total bases and home run markets. That gives people something concrete to argue about, which is what generates 700 comments rather than 70.
It also means the prices move. If you are betting props off that thread, the number you see at nine in the morning is frequently not the number available at seven in the evening, which is the strongest practical argument for holding accounts at more than one book. Our sportsbook rankings cover which ones price baseball props competitively.
Other places baseball betting gets discussed
- r/sportsbetting, 580,826 members, allows standalone posts. Use it when you want to ask something specific rather than drop a pick.
- r/PrizePicks, 125,001 members, and r/underdogfantasy, 47,417, are both heavy on baseball props through the summer.
- r/sportsbook runs a separate daily thread for the Asian leagues, covering KBO, NPB and CPBL. Small, and genuinely useful if you are one of the people betting overnight baseball.
- r/baseball and the team communities are fan spaces. Betting talk is not what they are for.
The off-season
The MLB threads vanish once the World Series ends and NFL takes over the slot. They return in late February with spring training and season win totals. If you have arrived in December and found nothing, that is why.
Questions people ask
Is there an MLB betting subreddit?
Not a dedicated one. r/MLBbets was banned by Reddit and nothing replaced it. Baseball betting discussion happens in the r/sportsbook daily threads, which are the busiest threads on that subreddit through the summer.
What is the busiest baseball betting thread on Reddit?
MLB Props and Home Run Picks on r/sportsbook, which typically runs between 413 and 724 comments a day in season. MLB Betting and Picks, covering moneylines, run lines and totals, is second at roughly 239 to 582.
Why does baseball have better Reddit coverage than football?
The schedule. Fifteen games a day for six months produces a volume of daily action that suits a daily thread format, whereas NFL concentrates into one day a week. Baseball props are also unusually data-driven, which generates more discussion per market.
Where do people bet and discuss KBO and NPB?
r/sportsbook runs a separate daily discussion thread covering KBO, NPB and CPBL. It is small compared with the MLB threads but it is the main place on Reddit for overnight Asian baseball markets.
Sportsbooks.ag may earn a commission from some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. That does not affect our reviews, ratings or recommendations. See our affiliate disclaimer, editorial policy and how we rate sportsbooks.