Home»NHL»New York Rangers vs Columbus Blue Jackets Pick & Prediction - March 19, 2026

New York Rangers vs Columbus Blue Jackets Pick & Prediction – March 19, 2026

Mike McDermott Mike McDermott
Mike McDermott
Mike McDermott
Sports Betting & iGaming Strategist
Mike McDermott is a seasoned sports betting expert and iGaming strategist with over 20 years of real-world experience in casinos, sportsbooks, and online gambling operations. He’s been deeply involved in the evolution of the iGaming industry from the early days of dial-up poker rooms to today’s highly regulated digital platforms
Read More
Sports Betting & iGaming Strategist, Updated March 18, 2026
Fact checked by: Alex Harper
Alex Harper
Alex Harper
Betting Education & Strategy Editor
Alex Harper is a betting education editor with more than 10 years of experience covering sports betting concepts, wager types, and responsible gambling practices. His work focuses on explaining betting mechanics clearly and accurately, including point spreads, totals, futures, parlays, and live betting markets. Alex’s guides are written to help bettors understand risk, probability, and betting structure rather than promote betting behavior.
Read More
Responsible Gaming
21+. Play responsibly. Betting involves risk. If you need help, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.
Affiliate Disclosure

Affiliate Disclosure

Our team of professional gambling site reviewers conducts independent research on every brand we feature on Sportsbooks.ag. We work with some partners on an affiliate basis but this does not affect our listings or ratings.

New York heads to Columbus on Thursday, March 19 (7:10 PM ET) with the Blue Jackets priced as a clear home favorite. Columbus is -225 on the moneyline, while the Rangers come back at +184.

With the total sitting at 6.5 and the Jackets laying -1.5 on the puck line, the market is expecting Columbus to control the game, but not necessarily in a low-scoring script.

In the Eastern race (records below are through March 9, 2026), Columbus is ahead of New York by 16 points and in a stronger position in the Wild Card chase.

Odds & Game Info

Odds as of 3:23 PM ET on March 18, 2026 (BetAnything).

Game infoDetails
MatchupNew York Rangers @ Columbus Blue Jackets
Date / TimeMarch 19, 2026, 7:10 PM ET
ArenaNationwide Arena (Columbus, OH)

Here are the current betting lines.

Spread (Puck Line)MoneylineTotal
CBJ -1.5 (+116)
NYR +1.5 (-142)		CBJ -225
NYR +184		Over 6.5 (+116)
Under 6.5 (-142)

Starting goalies have not been confirmed for this matchup as of the odds timestamp above.

Team Records

Records and recent form are listed below (through March 9, 2026).

TeamRecordLast 10
New York Rangers25-30-83-5-2
Columbus Blue Jackets32-21-106-1-3
Team records and team stats reference: 2025-26 NHL Statistics Release

Team Stats

These efficiency stats are season-to-date through March 9, 2026.

TeamGoals per gameGoals allowed per gamePower play %Penalty kill %
New York Rangers2.783.1723.6%77.8%
Columbus Blue Jackets3.243.2219.7%77.6%

Recaps

New York Rangers

New York’s profile is split heavily by venue: the Rangers were 17-15-2 on the road through March 9, but just 8-15-6 at home. The scoring margin was a concern overall (175 goals for, 200 against), and their last-10 stretch (3-5-2) reflects the inconsistency.

The clearest path for the Rangers to keep games competitive is special teams creation. Their power play was converting at 23.6% through March 9, which matters in this matchup because neither penalty kill was above 78%.

Columbus Blue Jackets

Columbus had the better record (32-21-10) but not a big goal cushion (204 for, 203 against), which is a big reason many Jackets games stayed tight into the third period. Their home record was strong at 17-8-7, and they were 6-1-3 in their last 10 through March 9.

Special teams were closer to league average than dominant: a 19.7% power play and a 77.6% penalty kill. That puts more weight on 5v5 finishing and protecting leads, especially against a Rangers team that can punish penalties.

Matchup Keys

  • One-goal game risk for Columbus: Columbus was just +1 in goal differential through March 9, and their home record includes 7 OT losses (17-8-7), a common footprint of tight finishes.
  • Rangers are materially better away from MSG: New York’s road record (17-15-2) was far more competitive than its home record (8-15-6) through March 9.
  • Special teams can swing it: NYR PP (23.6%) vs CBJ PK (77.6%) is a real leverage point, and CBJ PP (19.7%) vs NYR PK (77.8%) suggests Columbus can also cash if New York takes penalties.
  • Game script points to 6-plus goal potential: The teams combined for 6.02 goals per game scored, and 6.39 goals per game allowed (through March 9), which supports why 6.5 is the number.
  • Columbus was 17-8-7 at home through March 9.
  • New York was 17-15-2 on the road through March 9.
  • Columbus was 6-1-3 in its last 10 games through March 9.
  • New York was 3-5-2 in its last 10 games through March 9.
  • Columbus scored 3.24 goals per game through March 9, but allowed 3.22 per game (high-event mix).
  • New York allowed 3.17 goals per game through March 9, a tough baseline when catching +184.
  • New York’s power play (23.6%) ranked notably higher than Columbus’s (19.7%) through March 9.
  • Both teams were below 78% on the penalty kill through March 9 (NYR 77.8%, CBJ 77.6%).

Best Bet

Rangers +1.5 (-142)

Columbus deserves to be favored, but the profile through March 9 points to a lot of close outcomes: the Jackets were only +1 in goal differential and carried 7 overtime losses at home (17-8-7). New York’s road record (17-15-2) was also meaningfully better than its overall standing suggests, which makes +1.5 attractive in a game where Columbus is not consistently separating on the scoreboard. If the Rangers’ power play shows up (23.6% through March 9), they have a clean way to stay within one.

Predicted Score

Our computer projections model for this matchup predicts a final score of Blue Jackets 4, Rangers 3.

21+. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.