Western Michigan is the defending MAC champion, it’s 3-0 in league play, and it’s won three straight. Toledo just lost at home to Buffalo two weeks ago and is coming off a road win at Eastern Michigan. So why are the Rockets favored?
Because Toledo is the better team by almost every measure that matters. The Rockets average 6.7 yards per play to Western Michigan’s 5.4, and they have the much better quarterback. Western Michigan wins by running the ball, protecting it and keeping games short, and that works until it falls behind. I think Toledo builds a lead and makes the Broncos throw.
Western Michigan at Toledo: Odds and Game Info
- Kickoff: Saturday, Oct. 24, noon ET
- Stadium: Glass Bowl, Toledo, Ohio
- TV: CBS Sports Network
- Records: Western Michigan 5-2 (3-0 MAC), Toledo 5-2 (2-1 MAC)
- Coaches: Lance Taylor (Western Michigan), Mike Jacobs (Toledo)
| Source | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consensus | Toledo -3.5 | 45.5 | Toledo -175 / WMU +150 |
The line opened around Toledo -1.5 to -3 with a total of 44.5, and most books now have Toledo -3.5 and 45.5. A few still show -2.5.
Three is the key number. Toledo -2.5 wins on a three-point victory, -3 pushes and -3.5 loses. Toledo -2.5 at -124 means you need to win 55.4 percent of the time to break even, but that’s still worth it compared to laying the hook.
Both teams played last Saturday, and this is Western Michigan’s second straight road game. Toledo doesn’t play again until Nov. 4, so it has nothing to look ahead to. The winner gets to six wins and stays in the thick of the MAC race.
How They Got Here
| Western Michigan | Result | Toledo | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| at Michigan | L 13-12 | at Michigan State | L 30-20 |
| Monmouth (FCS) | W 49-14 | Central Connecticut (FCS) | W 63-10 |
| at Rice | W 28-21 | Temple | W 49-48 (OT) |
| Boise State | L 32-7 | San Diego State | W 41-16 |
| at Buffalo | W 20-17 | at Ball State | W 39-24 |
| Kent State | W 38-7 | Buffalo | L 23-8 |
| at Central Michigan | W 21-14 | at Eastern Michigan | W 34-14 |
Western Michigan nearly beat Michigan in the opener, losing 13-12 in Ann Arbor, which tells you how good its defense can be. But it also lost 32-7 to Boise State at home.
Both teams played Buffalo. Western Michigan won 20-17 on the road, while Toledo lost 23-8 at home. That’s the best argument for the Broncos, but Toledo beat itself in that game, as I’ll explain below.
Team Stats
| Stat | Western Michigan | Toledo |
|---|---|---|
| Points per game | 25.0 | 36.3 |
| Points allowed per game | 16.9 | 23.6 |
| Total yards per game | 322.3 | 459.0 |
| Passing yards per game | 157.6 | 273.4 |
| Rushing yards per game | 164.7 | 185.6 |
| Yards per play | 5.4 | 6.7 |
| Total yards allowed per game | 336.3 | 322.0 |
| Yards per play allowed | 5.0 | 4.6 |
| Yards per carry allowed | 3.7 | 3.4 |
| Third-down offense | 44.3% | 42.7% |
| Third-down defense | 38.5% | 36.0% |
| Turnover margin | +4 | Even |
| Penalty yards per game | 45.7 | 76.0 |
Take out the FCS games and Toledo still has a big scoring edge:
| FBS games only | Western Michigan | Toledo |
|---|---|---|
| Points per game | 21.0 | 31.8 |
| Points allowed per game | 17.3 | 25.8 |
Western Michigan allows fewer points, but Toledo’s defense is actually better on a per-play basis, giving up 4.6 yards per play to WMU’s 5.0. The Broncos’ advantages are ball security and discipline. They’re +4 in turnover margin and commit far fewer penalties.
Western Michigan Wins by Shortening the Game
Last week’s 21-14 win at Central Michigan was a perfect example. Western Michigan ran 45 times for 224 yards, and Broc Lowry threw just eight passes, completing five for 48 yards and a touchdown. The Broncos’ three touchdown drives took up about 20 and a half minutes combined. They led 21-0 after three quarters before Central Michigan scored twice late. CMU actually outgained them 337-272.
Jalen Buckley is the engine. He ran for 150 yards and two touchdowns against CMU and has 542 yards, 5.3 yards per carry and seven touchdowns this season.
Lowry is a game manager, and a good one. He’s completing 68 percent of his passes for 1,044 yards with eight touchdowns and one interception, and he’s run for 238 yards and three more scores. Aveion Chenault leads the receivers with 22 catches for 326 yards.
The problem is what happens if Western Michigan falls behind. Its passing offense averages just 157.6 yards per game and ranks near the bottom of the country in efficiency. The Broncos aren’t built to come from behind.
Toledo Has the Better Quarterback
John Alan Richter is the biggest difference in this game. He’s 144 of 218 for 1,853 yards with 14 touchdowns and one interception, averaging about 8.5 yards per attempt. Both quarterbacks have one interception, but Richter gives Toledo far more through the air.
He was sharp at Eastern Michigan last week, going 24 of 30 for 288 yards and a touchdown. Toledo scored on all five first-half possessions and led 31-7 at halftime. Autavius Ison ran for 104 yards and a touchdown, and CJ Miller added two more rushing scores. Toledo outgained Eastern Michigan 480-276.
The defense was just as impressive. Toledo held EMU to 34 rushing yards on 28 carries and recorded six sacks. Andrew Zock, the 2025 FCS Defensive Player of the Year, had two sacks and nine tackles.
What Went Wrong Against Buffalo
Toledo’s 23-8 home loss to Buffalo is the reason I’m not more confident. The Rockets didn’t score until the fourth quarter, committed 137 penalty yards, lost a fumble that set up a short field and missed a field goal. It ended a nine-game home winning streak.
That game wasn’t as one-sided as the final score looked. Buffalo outgained Toledo just 351-308, and 87 of Buffalo’s 180 rushing yards came on one long touchdown run. Penalties are still a problem, though. Toledo committed 118 penalty yards against Eastern Michigan and averages 76.0 per game. Western Michigan is disciplined enough to take advantage.
The Matchups That Decide It
Buckley vs. Toledo’s run defense: This is the matchup that decides the game. Toledo allows just 3.4 yards per carry and just held Eastern Michigan to 34 rushing yards. If the Rockets slow down Buckley, Western Michigan ends up in third-and-long, and Lowry has to throw. That’s exactly where Toledo wants the game.
Richter vs. Western Michigan’s defense: The Broncos allow just 16.9 points per game, but they haven’t faced many quarterbacks like Richter. Toledo can score from anywhere on the field.
Toledo’s penalties: This is Western Michigan’s best path to an upset. Penalties extend drives and wipe out big plays, and in a game lined at a field goal, a few flags could decide it.
Injuries
| Team | Player | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Toledo | WR R. Bond | Questionable |
| Toledo | RB C. Smith | Questionable |
| Toledo | TE T. Kelleher | Out |
| Toledo | WR K. Gilbert Jr. | Out |
| Toledo | WR T. Jones | Out |
Western Michigan has no players listed, but that doesn’t guarantee everyone is healthy. Toledo is thin at receiver, which is worth watching given how much it relies on the passing game. Both starting quarterbacks played last week.
Trends and Series History
| Betting record | Western Michigan | Toledo |
|---|---|---|
| Against the spread | 3-4 | 3-4 |
| Over/Under | 3-4 | 5-2 |
| Home record | 2-1 | 3-1 |
| Road record | 3-1 | 2-1 |
- Western Michigan has won three straight but covered only one of them.
- The underdog is 4-0 ATS in the last four meetings.
- The home team has won the last six meetings.
- Toledo leads the all-time series 46-33.
| Year | Result |
|---|---|
| 2025 | Western Michigan 14, Toledo 13 (Kalamazoo) |
| 2023 | Toledo 49, Western Michigan 31 (Toledo) |
| 2022 | Western Michigan 20, Toledo 14 |
| 2021 | Toledo 34, Western Michigan 15 |
Western Michigan won last year’s meeting on a late touchdown and a two-point conversion. Both coaching staffs have changed since then, so I wouldn’t lean on the series too much.
Weather
The early forecast calls for mostly sunny skies, a high near 62 degrees and light wind. Weather shouldn’t be a factor.
What the Models Say
- Dimers projects Toledo 24-22 with a 58.8 percent win probability, and gives WMU +3.5 a 54 percent chance to cover.
- ESPN’s model gives Toledo a 53 percent chance to win.
- Tony’s Picks likes Toledo -3.
- SportsbookReview likes the Toledo moneyline.
Western Michigan vs. Toledo Pick and Prediction
Toledo is the side. It has the better quarterback, the better yards-per-play numbers on both sides of the ball, and a run defense that’s built to stop exactly what Western Michigan wants to do. If Toledo gets an early lead, the Broncos’ offense isn’t built to come back.
Western Michigan is well coached, protects the ball and won’t beat itself, so this probably won’t be a blowout. That’s why the number matters so much. I’d lay -2.5. At -3, it’s a small play. At -3.5, I’d pass, since a field-goal win is a very real outcome here.
I’m passing on the total. Western Michigan’s ball-control style points to the Under, but Toledo’s passing game and penalty issues could push it Over. At 45.5, I don’t see an edge.
- Toledo -2.5: My best bet. Shop for it.
- Toledo -3: A small play. Pass at -3.5.
- Total: No play at 45.5.
- Richter passing yards: Worth a look once props are posted.
Prediction: Toledo 26, Western Michigan 20
Best Bet: Toledo -2.5
Odds are subject to change. Please bet responsibly.