Both of these teams are 4-1. Both are coming off ugly offensive performances on Saturday. And both are on a short week heading into a Thursday night ESPN game at the Alamodome.
The market has UTSA as roughly a touchdown favorite, and the public seems happy to lay it. I’m not. South Florida has the best defense in this game, and I don’t trust either offense enough to lay seven points.
South Florida at UTSA: Odds and Game Info
- Kickoff: Thursday, Oct. 8, 7:30 p.m. ET (6:30 p.m. CT)
- Stadium: Alamodome, San Antonio (indoors)
- TV: ESPN
- Records: South Florida 4-1 (1-1 American), UTSA 4-1 (1-0 American)
- Spread: UTSA -7
- Total: 50.5
- Moneyline: UTSA -261, South Florida +223
The spread is scattered across the key number, so shopping matters more than usual. USF +7.5 covers a seven-point loss. +7 pushes. +6.5 loses. If you’re on the Bulls, find the hook.
The total also varies. Some books opened it in the mid-50s, and it’s been bet down to around 50 to 50.5. That move makes sense after what both offenses did last weekend.
Both Offenses Just Hit a Wall
South Florida lost 17-13 to Temple at home, ending a nine-game home winning streak. The Bulls led 13-10 in the fourth quarter before giving up a 96-yard touchdown drive. They’ve scored 27 points combined in their last two games, and they were scoreless through three quarters at Bowling Green the week before.
UTSA beat Rice 16-14, but the offense scored only one touchdown and was shut out in the second half. The Roadrunners settled for field goals and couldn’t break a play longer than 23 yards.
One week earlier, UTSA beat Colorado State 59-45. That’s the range of outcomes with this team.
What the Numbers Say Against FBS Teams
Here’s how each season has gone:
| South Florida | UTSA |
|---|---|
| Beat FIU 19-9 | Beat UTRGV 45-16 |
| Won at Army 28-24 | Won at Texas State 31-26 |
| Beat Delaware State 59-17 | Lost at Texas 30-6 |
| Won at Bowling Green 14-6 | Beat Colorado State 59-45 |
| Lost to Temple 17-13 | Won at Rice 16-14 |
Take out each team’s FCS opponent and the picture changes:
| vs. FBS Opponents | Points Scored | Points Allowed |
|---|---|---|
| South Florida | 18.5 | 14.0 |
| UTSA | 28.0 | 28.8 |
UTSA’s schedule includes a trip to Texas, so it’s not a perfect comparison. But it tells you the basic story. UTSA scores more and gives up a lot. USF can’t score but rarely lets anyone else score either.
South Florida’s Defense Is the Best Unit on the Field
The Bulls allow 14.6 points per game and 3.8 yards per carry. Against Temple, they held the Owls to 274 yards and 5-of-12 on third down, and C.J. Hicks recovered a fumble in the end zone to take points off the board. Linebacker Grayson “Pup” Howard is back from an early-season injury and had nine tackles.
The one late drive hurt, and two USF penalties on it made it worse. But this defense has kept the Bulls in every game.
South Florida’s Offense Is the Problem
This is the first year under Brian Hartline, who replaced Alex Golesh, and the offense hasn’t found its footing.
Quarterback Michael Van Buren Jr., an LSU transfer, has protected the ball. He’s completing about 63 percent with no interceptions. He’s also shown he can make plays when it matters: he accounted for all four touchdowns in the comeback at Army, including a 38-yard fourth-down strike with 19 seconds left.
But the Bulls just don’t finish drives. Against Temple, Van Buren went 17 of 32 for 205 yards and USF managed one touchdown. Running back D.J. Crowther was held to 68 yards on 23 carries after back-to-back 100-yard games. The Bulls also committed eight penalties.
The offensive line is a big part of the problem. USF has used four different starting combinations up front, with Michael Wooten and Thomas Shrader both dealing with injuries. Check the availability report before you bet. A healthier line would make me feel better about the Bulls.
The Matchup That Gives USF a Chance: Its Run Game vs. UTSA’s Defense
UTSA’s run defense has been bad. The Roadrunners allow 199.4 rushing yards per game and 4.7 yards per carry. Colorado State put up 45 points on them, and Jeff Traylor admitted afterward his team couldn’t stop anybody.
That’s where USF can steal this. If Crowther and the line get going on early downs, Van Buren isn’t stuck in third-and-long, the Bulls keep the ball and UTSA’s offense sits on the sideline. That’s exactly how an underdog with a great defense stays within a touchdown.
UTSA’s Offense Is Better, but It Isn’t Consistent
Owen McCown is the more experienced quarterback. He has 1,010 passing yards with seven touchdowns and two interceptions, completing 68.2 percent. Against Colorado State he threw for 303 yards and three scores.
Then against Rice, he went 19 of 29 for 148 yards with no touchdowns and an interception, and he lost a fumble on a strip sack. Rice’s young pass rush got to him, and USF’s defense is better than Rice’s.
The Roadrunners do have depth at running back. Will Henderson III has 398 yards at 6.1 per carry. Brandon High Jr. and A’Marion Peterson add another 400-plus yards and six touchdowns between them. DJ Allen and Mekhi Anderson are the top receivers.
Kicker Michael Petro hit three field goals at Rice, including a 53-yarder. That’s nice, but it’s also a sign of an offense that stalled in the red zone.
Home Field Is Real at the Alamodome
The case for UTSA starts here. Traylor is 35-6 at the Alamodome, and UTSA is 25-1 in conference home games since 2020. ESPN’s SportsCenter on Campus will be in the building, and the crowd should be loud.
That’s a big reason I think UTSA wins this game. It’s not a reason to lay seven points. Those records are about winning, not covering.
USF has also handled the road well this year. The Bulls are 2-0 away from home, including that comeback win at Army.
The Short Week
Both teams played Saturday, so it’s a five-day turnaround on each side. UTSA only had to travel from Houston, while USF has to fly from Tampa to San Antonio. That’s a slight edge for the Roadrunners, and part of why the line sits where it does.
The Series
These teams are 1-1 all-time. UTSA won 49-21 in San Antonio in 2023, and USF won 55-23 in Tampa last November. Both programs have new quarterbacks and USF has a new head coach since then, so I don’t weigh either result much.
Trends
Both teams have gone under in three of their five games. USF is 2-3 against the spread, and UTSA is 3-2. Public money has been heavily on UTSA at one consensus site, which is another reason I’m happy to be on the other side.
South Florida vs. UTSA Pick and Prediction
UTSA should win this game. It has home field, the better quarterback and more ways to score. I’m not arguing that.
But laying seven points requires UTSA’s offense to look like it did against Colorado State, not like it did at Rice. Against the best defense it’s seen outside of Texas, I don’t expect a blowout. USF’s running game has a real matchup against UTSA’s front, and the Bulls’ defense should keep this close into the fourth quarter.
Here’s how I’d play it:
- South Florida +7.5: My best bet. At +7, it’s a weaker lean because a one-touchdown loss only pushes. I’d pass at +6.5.
- Under 51.5: Both offenses just struggled, USF can’t finish drives and UTSA settled for field goals last week. I’d play it at 51 or higher, but pass if it drops to 49.5.
- Moneyline: USF at +225 is tempting for a small sprinkle, but I expect UTSA to win. No play for me.
Prediction: UTSA 27, South Florida 21
Best Bet: South Florida +7.5
Second Play: Under 50.5
Odds are subject to change. Please bet responsibly.